Why Did Nat Pick James?

Unlike a lot of people, I sort of understand why people voted the way they did.

Ryan went for the returning contestant in hopes that it was his girlfriend Jen.

Matt voted the same way hoping for Alex, but not having any problems with Amanda's return.

Sheila wisely chose to not bring back the person she just evicted.

It's pretty obvious why Chelsia voted the way she did.

Sharon was scared her ex-boyfriend may return; Joshuah had the same fear about Allison (and he was working with James).

Adam's vote for James is a bit of a surprise, but there are reports that he had some sort of beef with Parker. Can anybody verify that?

But the dumbest vote was Natalie's. She had no reason to vote for James. She was on good terms with almost all of the evictees. Alex, Amanda, Parker, and Jen would have all helped tip the balance against the side of house she hates. Even Allison could have been good for her, as she would have clearly gone after Joshuah.

Even if he had not won HOH, bringing James back is a disaster for Nat. It brings balance back to the house, and puts everybody in her group in danger. Plus, bragging about being the "deciding vote" sets her up to the be among the first of her group to go once they have to start putting each other up.

It's a dumb, dumb move for her...but should we be surprised?